Michael Nutley

Gold-plated writing for the AI age.

AI baselineHuman craft

Most copy lands at ninety-five per cent. Polished, correct, finished by something that has read everything and felt nothing. The last five per cent is the part you remember a week later. It's the part nobody is teaching a machine to do. That's what I am for.

AI will get a draft ninety-five per cent of the way there. I write the five per cent that gives it taste, rhythm, and the line a reader actually remembers.

Start a conversation
Drag the gold marker on any paragraph. Slide left for the human-written version. Slide right for the AI-assisted baseline. Same argument, different writer.

The locomotive and the stagecoach

AI baselineHuman craft

AI is the locomotive. It runs the route on time, at scale, between two points it has been told are the start and the end. New York to Los Angeles for tuppence. Brilliant. Buy a ticket.

AI is a locomotive. It will take you from New York to Los Angeles, and it will do it faster and cheaper than anything that came before it. What it cannot do is get you to La Jolla.

AI baselineHuman craft

What it cannot do is take you to La Jolla. That last bit, the bit where the writing has to know who it is talking to, why it cares, and how to land, is stagecoach work. Slow, deliberate, expensive per mile, and the only part of the journey the reader will thank you for.

For that you need a stagecoach. Someone who knows the road, the destination, and the reader at the other end of it. AI gets the volume out of the door. A human gets it across the last mile, which is the only mile that converts.


The cost of pure AI

AI baselineHuman craft

AI-assisted writing is not an edge any more. Every agency has it, every in-house team has it, every freelancer with a free trial has it. The floor went up. The ceiling did not. The data is starting to show where the gap landed.

AI-assisted writing is the new baseline, not the new advantage. The platforms have automated it; everyone has access to it; everyone is producing more of it. The data on what happens next is starting to land.

−14%

Lower purchase intent when readers identify content as AI-generated.

−17%

Drop in premium perception for the same content when seen as AI-made.

Cross-platform creative benchmarks, 2026.

AI baselineHuman craft

The more your reader has to think before buying, the worse pure AI does. Below a hundred dollars the machine holds its own. Above five hundred it converts fourteen per cent worse. In long-form, human writing pulls roughly four times the organic traffic over five months. People feel the difference. They do not always say so. They just stop reading, or do not buy, or buy from someone else.

The further up the consideration scale you go, the worse pure AI performs. On purchases over $500, AI-generated creative converts 14% worse than human-written. On long-form, human-written articles attract roughly four times the organic traffic of AI-only equivalents over a five-month window.


Where the value moves to

+26%

Click-through rate uplift for human-edited AI copy over AI-only copy on Facebook dynamic product ads.

Organic traffic advantage for human long-form over pure-AI articles over five months.

Pencil ad-creative study, 2026; techRT meta-analysis, 2026.

AI baselineHuman craft

The data tells one story over and over. Hybrid wins. AI does the bulk. A human with thirty years of taste decides what survives, what gets binned, what gets written from a blank page. That is the part that gets more valuable the more of the other you make.

The pattern across the data is the same. Hybrid beats pure AI. The work that lands is AI for volume, scaffolded by someone with taste who knows what to keep, what to cut, and what to write from scratch. That is where the value moves.


What AI cannot do

AI baselineHuman craft

It can structure. It can summarise. It can produce a draft at four in the morning that would have taken three people a fortnight in 2023. None of that is the difficult bit.

It can structure. It can summarise. It can produce a competent draft at a scale that was not possible eighteen months ago.

AI baselineHuman craft

What it cannot do is taste. It cannot read a room. It cannot find the sentence that turns a scroller into a buyer. It cannot leave the fingerprints on a page that tell the reader the writer was once seventeen and embarrassed about something, and now writes for a living.

It cannot taste. It cannot read a room. It cannot find the sentence that turns a reader from a scroll into a decision. It cannot leave the tear-splots on the printed page that make a piece of writing feel like it was written by a person who has lived a little.

AI baselineHuman craft

That bit is craft. Craft does not get cheaper when the volume goes up. It gets rarer, and worth more, and harder to find. Always has.

That is craft. That is the part that does not get cheaper, and the part that gets more valuable the more abundant the alternative becomes.


Who this is for

AI baselineHuman craft

You already use AI. The tooling is in place, the team knows the prompts, the output is up. The week is full of things you did not have to write yourself.

You already use AI. You have the bandwidth, the tooling, and the output. You are shipping more, faster, than your competitors.

AI baselineHuman craft

Then someone reads three of your competitors' newsletters next to yours and says they all sound a bit the same. The same opening. The same rhythm. The same hedge in the third paragraph. You knew before they said it. You had noticed. So have the readers, who say nothing, they just open less often.

And you have noticed that your output now reads like everybody else's output. The same cadence. The same hedges. The same ending. You can feel the difference between the draft the machine produced and the version a careful human would have written, and so can your readers.

AI baselineHuman craft

What you want is for the work to sound like you again, and for it to do the thing the work used to do, which was make people stop and read. That is the gap I fill.

You want the work to sound like you, and convert like a craftsperson wrote it. That is what I am for.


What I do


About Michael Nutley

AI baselineHuman craft

Michael has been writing about digital marketing since most of the people running digital marketing departments today were at primary school. Thirty years, give or take.

Michael has been writing about, and shaping, digital media and marketing for over thirty years.

He edited New Media Age, the UK's leading news publication for interactive business, from 2000 to 2007, and was its editor-in-chief from 2007 to 2011. He went on to head content at Digital Doughnut, edit the European channel of Adobe's CMO.com, and now writes original research and long-form work for B2B technology and marketing brands as principal writer at London Research.

He writes regularly for The Drum and has bylines across Marketing Week and the wider UK trade press. He has lectured on the future of advertising and publishing at the London College of Communications, and is a regular speaker at industry events including Advertising Week Europe.

He is, by any reasonable measure, one of the most senior digital writers working in the UK.


How I work

AI baselineHuman craft

I take a few projects a year. I charge for them properly. Gold-plating takes longer than ninety-five per cent, and clients who want the last five per cent know why they are paying for it.

I take a small number of projects each year. I work at premium rates because gold-plated work costs more to produce and is worth more to the people commissioning it.

AI baselineHuman craft

If your project is not a fit I will tell you in the first email. If it is, you will have the attention of someone who has been at this since before banner ads.

If your project is not a fit, I will tell you. If it is, you will get the attention of someone who has spent thirty years learning how to make writing land.


Start a conversation

Tell me about the project. A paragraph is enough. I read every enquiry myself.

Email Michael